The Iliad focuses its narrative on the glories of heroes in the Trojan War, particular Achilles and Hector. Although both are heroes for their side, they have complex personalities that explain their actions. Indeed, as one reads through the poem, it seems that they have nothing in common. They do not share motives for fighting, similar views concerning the immortals, or perspective concerning relationships of those around them, yet they are united by characteristics that constitute a hero as we understand one.
Despite their differences, Achilles and Hector both place value on bravery, fight on behalf of others, and see the humanity in those they are fighting with and against. Achilles is the epic hero in The Iliad. Achilles is the best warrior of the Achaeans and Hector was the top warrior for the Trojans. Although Achilles and Hector seem very similar, they actually have a lot of differences between the two of them, which makes each of them unique. The similarities are prominent between Achilles and Hector, but they were different in the way the way they lived, why they fought, and by their mentality.
It all began when King Agememnon was asked to return. Both Achilles and Diomedes easily meet the first requirement, that a hero must have skill on the battlefield. Throughout The Iliad, Homer tells of their incredible though usually go Not many men met all requirements, including Achilles, but they were still viewed as heroes.
Between Achilles and Diomedes, Diomedes was the better choice for the title of hero. He was one of the finest Greek soldiers. Homer's poem the "Iliad" describes a long and brutal war between the Greeks and the Trojans. The leaders of these two armies Achilles and Hector were two great warriors that fought for honor and their people, they were very respected amongst their people and were considered to be heroes.
These two characters play a large role in Homer's poem "Iliad" as the whole story revolves around them and their actions. Even though Achilles and Hector are great warriors they differ in the way they treat their families, the way they lead their men into battle, the reasons they fight, and the way they view and act towards the gods. Hector fights primarily because he feels that he has a responsibility to his city and his family. Home Page Achilles Vs. Achilles Vs. Hector Satisfactory Essays.
Open Document. Essay Sample Check Writing Quality. Achilles and Hector are both great men and strong warriors, but they differ in many ways. When contrasting Hector and Achilles it is quite apparent who the better hero is of the two, Hector. Although Achilles is a powerful leader, a strong warrior, and has good traits about himself they do not amount to those of Hector.
Achilles and Hector although, both strong warriors differ in their leadership, human qualities, and family lives. Even he was kind to Helen, the main cause of the destructive battle between the Trojans and the Greeks and was very much tolerant of her faults.
Battle and acts of bravery are constantly taking place throughout the epic. It is obvious that the people living in the times of Homer took war very seriously and gave much honor and respect to those that showed bravery in battle. Undoubtedly, Hector and Achilles show much bravery in battle. Simply by participating in the bloody war they prove that they are formidable and honorable men that value bravery.
But in their own way, and at certain times, they are either proven completely not brave, or at the very least, avoiding battle for reasons that they believe are astute at the time.
First, Hector shows the only true cowardice when he learns that Achilles is on his way to avenge Patroclus. He runs around the city walls three walls in an attempt to forestall the fight that is to ensue. Only when Athena takes the shape of Deiphobus and assures Hector that they will fight Achilles together does Hector regain his courage. But even when he does muster the courage to go face Achilles, he begins to tremble at the sight of Achilles in all his rage.
Also, it could be argued, that while Achilles does have courage, he shirks from battle when he has his disagreement with Agamemnon. Achilles is a product of the heroic age when to be soft and meek is unthinkable. Everything about Achilles is keyed to the highest pitch. He is strong in his likings and dislikings.
For Hector, Achilles is an unassailable figure. He cannot be ignored, cannot be avoided, cannot be defeated, cannot even at the end be confronted with dignity. Throughout the story, Achilles remains to Hector a riddle an uncomprehended force. Between these two heroes there is a kind of vacant space at the center of the Iliad. This vacancy, at the end the poet reveals to us. Achilles is the great hero of the Iliad, and the Iliad is the story of the death of a hero, but Achilles does not die in the Iliad.
The death of Achilles or rather, his morality is a ruling fatality of the Iliad, but the pathos of the poem is concentrated in the death of Hector. The writer is a freelance contributor. More From inscription. Video Gallery. In this paper I will highlight the life of both of these two leaders of the Greek and Trojans in this epic the. This was because Hector had been a brave leader by fighting for his family, friends, city, and citizens.
Hector has proved himself to be more of a hero than Achilles ever was. Hector had made decisions based on what he had known was the right choice. He knew he angered someone that loved that person very much. So when Achilles had asked him to meet him. Both have strengths and weaknesses, which are apparent throughout the conflicts in the epic poem. They have obvious differences and limited similarities, which logically lends itself to the idea of who is more admirable.
On one hand there is Achilles, a great warrior, son of Thetis and King Peleus, and notorious for his anger. This is shown when Achilles addresses King Agamemnon. Hector The Iliad is an epic poem usually attributed to Homer. The poem narrates the story of the war between the Greeks and the Trojans, known as the Trojan War. Angry by the kidnapping of his wife, Menelaus king of Sparta asks his brother the King Agamemnon king of the Achaeans to march to war against the Trojans.
The war is fought in the outskirts of Troy, and lasted ten years. The importance. In The Iliad, both Achilles and Hector are considered epic heroes. Achilles and Hector are both great warriors, courageous, have Battlefield honor, and bold. Achilles and Hector have the similarity of both being great and skilled warriors. Achilles is a warrior who fights for the Greeks, while Hector is the leader and a warrior of the Trojan Army. Achilles and Hector are both at the same level of warrior greatness but Achilles is more skilled than Hector.
The Greeks see him as a great. Book nine is considered to be the climax of the Iliad because it is a turning point in the war and the Greeks realize that they need Achilles. Agamemnon offers a multitude of gifts and gives a rather lame apology in the hopes of Achilles returning, however Achilles refuses the gifts.
0コメント